Help
Now for GIB 4♣ is natural, but as it does not deny the 5-card ♥, I really don't get the Pass, but I assume it is because BEN never had been trained with that sequence.
Ben on BBO - Feedback thread Discussions about Ben models trained on BBO data
#161
- Group: Members
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 2024-April-29
Posted 2024-August-07, 15:53
A splinter disaster
Now for GIB 4♣ is natural, but as it does not deny the 5-card ♥, I really don't get the Pass, but I assume it is because BEN never had been trained with that sequence.
Now for GIB 4♣ is natural, but as it does not deny the 5-card ♥, I really don't get the Pass, but I assume it is because BEN never had been trained with that sequence.
I am BEN the Bridge ENgine
#162
- Group: Members
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 2024-April-29
Posted 2024-August-13, 07:56
Annoying that BEN is not bidding the same each time
23 players saw BEN bid the very strange 2♥
One lucky player got the more natural 2♠ and scored 100%.
Also worth noting the failure to cover ♠9 at trick 7.
23 players saw BEN bid the very strange 2♥
One lucky player got the more natural 2♠ and scored 100%.
Also worth noting the failure to cover ♠9 at trick 7.
I am BEN the Bridge ENgine
#163
- Group: Members
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 2024-April-29
Posted 2024-August-15, 09:25
Testing two different models from BEN in the wild I noticed this strange situation.
Just to clarify: I am using the Open Source version of BEN as participant in the BEN and Freinds daily, so there are 4 BEN's but one (south) is not controlled by BBO
e
Down 1 and a fine score of 64%
Using the new bidding model all was the same until trick 6, where BEN suddenly found a much better plan.
Making an overtrick and a score of 1.2%
Please remove the randomness in the BBO-BEN
Just to clarify: I am using the Open Source version of BEN as participant in the BEN and Freinds daily, so there are 4 BEN's but one (south) is not controlled by BBO
e
Down 1 and a fine score of 64%
Using the new bidding model all was the same until trick 6, where BEN suddenly found a much better plan.
Making an overtrick and a score of 1.2%
Please remove the randomness in the BBO-BEN
I am BEN the Bridge ENgine
#164
- Group: Members
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 2024-April-29
Posted 2024-August-20, 10:16
I am not sure anyone still read this thread :-)
But this is interesting, because BEN haven't been trained in the default GIB system
Explanation is correct, but BBO-BEN just passed.
And yes, the south hand is not good enough for 4♥, but I will discuss that with the open source version of BEN.
But this is interesting, because BEN haven't been trained in the default GIB system
Explanation is correct, but BBO-BEN just passed.
And yes, the south hand is not good enough for 4♥, but I will discuss that with the open source version of BEN.
I am BEN the Bridge ENgine
#165
- Group: Members
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 2024-July-11
Posted 2024-September-18, 14:29
pilowsky, on 2024-January-05, 15:39, said:
The end of the world is nigh.
It is refreshing not to have Best Hand deals. Closer to real bridge. Still needs some work though
#166
- Group: Members
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 2024-September-22
Posted 2024-September-22, 08:30
Interested in playing w Ben in 8 board invite tourney.
#167
- Group: Members
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 2020-November-02
Posted 2024-October-02, 01:43
Post in the Ben on BBO BBO Forums thread to be added to the tournament
#168
- Group: Members
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 2024-April-29
Posted 2024-October-04, 14:20
mstockyard, on 2024-September-22, 08:30, said:
Interested in playing w Ben in 8 board invite tourney.
If you are interested in playing with the Open Source version of BEN (Not the BBO version) I might be able to set it up.
As a start feel free to challenge the Robot on BBO (Name is TwoOneBEN). In a challenge you will play 3 GIB-robots, and the compare with your opponent. Then you can get an impression of the strength and especially weaknesses of the robot.
I am BEN the Bridge ENgine
#169
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 3,774
- Joined: 2019-October-04
- Gender:Male
- Location:Poland
Posted 2024-October-09, 23:48
Is this a bidding misunderstanding? https://tinyurl.com/ytepqw8f
Fortuna Fortis Felix
#170
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 3,774
- Joined: 2019-October-04
- Gender:Male
- Location:Poland
Posted 2024-October-25, 00:38
Ben bids like a human: https://tinyurl.com/22oc5kvm
Fortuna Fortis Felix
#171
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 5,041
- Joined: 2008-September-10
- Gender:Male
Posted 2024-October-25, 01:47
pilowsky, on 2024-October-25, 00:38, said:
Ben bids like a human: https://tinyurl.com/22oc5kvm
Very unlucky hand where ♣A was in the wrong hand. And very unsporting of you to double.
#172
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 4,044
- Joined: 2014-March-15
- Gender:Male
Posted 2024-October-25, 02:03
Auction seems to scream for a low club lead.
(I'm still trying to figure out how I scored more than 50% on this hand, though
)
(I'm still trying to figure out how I scored more than 50% on this hand, though
)
#173
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 4,044
- Joined: 2014-March-15
- Gender:Male
Posted 2024-November-05, 15:26
pilowsky, on 2024-March-02, 20:37, said:
thorvald, on 2024-April-21, 16:34, said:
Interesting that 26 times North opened a 4th hand 2♦, and one time the Robot in West did not balance with 3♥
TwoOneBEN, on 2024-May-31, 09:31, said:
Inconsistent bidding.
TwoOneBEN, on 2024-June-04, 05:43, said:
South open 1N once, and 1♥ 38 times
TwoOneBEN, on 2024-June-26, 06:49, said:
As far as I can see we got two different defences but bidding and play was identical up the point
TwoOneBEN, on 2024-August-13, 07:56, said:
Annoying that BEN is not bidding the same each time
And a couple of days ago, a 1.7% board for me because the defense differed at my table only.
It seems Ben and lorserker have met the same fate as GIB and jdonn
#174
- Group: Admin
- Posts: 5,007
- Joined: 2009-July-26
- Gender:Female
- Location:bucharest / romania
Posted 2024-November-05, 16:31
Nope, we're still alive and following
#175
- Group: Full Members
- Posts: 102
- Joined: 2007-November-26
Posted 2024-November-19, 05:58
Updated the robot in Ben & Friends.
If you run into oddities, please raise them.
If you run into oddities, please raise them.
#176
- Group: Members
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 2020-October-12
Posted 2024-November-22, 02:01
I'm not sure if this is a Ben error or a BBO error, but I'm currently stuck on the first board of the Goulash with Ben Daily.
I've bid to what I assume will be the final contract, but instead of passing out the Ben sitting East hangs. After a bit the table closes with an "An error has occurred...GIB Ask Failed: ERROR(2): Robot Error" message. Reopening the table leads to the same issue.
I've bid to what I assume will be the final contract, but instead of passing out the Ben sitting East hangs. After a bit the table closes with an "An error has occurred...GIB Ask Failed: ERROR(2): Robot Error" message. Reopening the table leads to the same issue.
#177
- Group: Admin
- Posts: 5,007
- Joined: 2009-July-26
- Gender:Female
- Location:bucharest / romania
Posted 2024-November-22, 06:16
kcostell, on 2024-November-22, 02:01, said:
I'm not sure if this is a Ben error or a BBO error, but I'm currently stuck on the first board of the Goulash with Ben Daily.
I've bid to what I assume will be the final contract, but instead of passing out the Ben sitting East hangs. After a bit the table closes with an "An error has occurred...GIB Ask Failed: ERROR(2): Robot Error" message. Reopening the table leads to the same issue.
I've bid to what I assume will be the final contract, but instead of passing out the Ben sitting East hangs. After a bit the table closes with an "An error has occurred...GIB Ask Failed: ERROR(2): Robot Error" message. Reopening the table leads to the same issue.
The goulash game was mis-configured, sorry about that. We removed it and we'll post it again tomorrow.
Thanks for letting us know.