I wonder why GIB think it is right to bid 2♦ and not 2♣
Page 1 of 1
Bidding a higher 3-card suit before a 5-card suit
#1
Posted 2023-March-05, 15:05
I wonder why GIB think it is right to bid 2♦ and not 2♣
Thorvald Aagaard
Mobile : +45 22 99 55 25
http://www.netbridge.dk
http://www.thorvald.dk
Mobile : +45 22 99 55 25
http://www.netbridge.dk
http://www.thorvald.dk
#3
Posted 2023-March-05, 17:21
Back to another earlier discussion point about whether zero is an even number in RKCB
But the void does appear to be useful
I know GiB only promises some void - no promise of being useful - but in this case
But the void does appear to be useful
I know GiB only promises some void - no promise of being useful - but in this case
#4
Posted 2023-March-05, 18:40
Its rules for this situation when it's weak and picking a suit, in order:
1: bid 2H if your longest suit is a 5 card minor, and your second longest suit is 4 hearts
2: bid 2x if x is your longest suit, and x isn't spades, and it's at least 5 cards long
3: bid 2x if x is your longest suit, and x isn't spades, and it's exactly 4 cards long
4: bid 2x if your longest suit is spades, and x is your second longest suit, and it's exactly 4 cards long
5: bid 2x for any x other than spades which is exactly 3 cards long
Pretty clear logical error in the database, missing the case when you have 5 spades and 5 of something else.
And yes, this means if you make North 5125, it will pass the double, not because it wants to penalise, but because now none of these rules match.
1: bid 2H if your longest suit is a 5 card minor, and your second longest suit is 4 hearts
2: bid 2x if x is your longest suit, and x isn't spades, and it's at least 5 cards long
3: bid 2x if x is your longest suit, and x isn't spades, and it's exactly 4 cards long
4: bid 2x if your longest suit is spades, and x is your second longest suit, and it's exactly 4 cards long
5: bid 2x for any x other than spades which is exactly 3 cards long
Pretty clear logical error in the database, missing the case when you have 5 spades and 5 of something else.
And yes, this means if you make North 5125, it will pass the double, not because it wants to penalise, but because now none of these rules match.
I have nothing worth contributing, bye
Page 1 of 1

Help

